Samsung Galaxy S Review

It used to be that HTC was the clear-cut leader in the smartphone arena, but many other companies are competing for the crown these days. HTC isn’t the only Android game in town and Samsung has really carved a nice-sized market share for itself with the Galaxy S line. Even more so as of recent with the introduction of the Google Nexus S. The Samsung Galaxy S is offered as the AT&T Captivate, T-Mobile Vibrant, Verizon Fascinate, Sprint Epic 4G and Rogers Captivate.

I had the opportunity to take this Android smartphone out for a test drive and, by and large, I was quite impressed with what it had to offer and how usable it was as a daily communicator. The┬áGalaxy S Captivate may not be all that different from its other Galaxy S stablemates, but that’s not necessarily a bad thing either.

Features and Specifications

As a quick rundown, the Captivate has many of the same features that you’ll find on the other Galaxy S devices, like the Fascinate. It doesn’t rock the hardware keyboard of the Epic 4G from Sprint, but this allows it to have a very impressive sub-10mm profile. It also weighs in at a feather light 125 grams, making it feel thinner and lighter than a certain iDevice competitor.

For my part, the most captivating feature on this phone had to be the four-inch Super AMOLED display. The 800×480 WVGA resolution is pretty much par for the course, but the colors really do “pop” off the screen. You’ll get tri-band HSPA (7.2Mbps), quad-band GSM, WiFi, GPS, Android 2.1 preloaded (Froyo update on the way), Bluetooth, and microSD expansion slot.

It Starts with an Amazing Display

If you’ve never had the opportunity to play with a Samsung phone rocking a Super AMOLED display, you’re in for a real treat. It is not at all an exaggeration to say that the contrast is positively brilliant and the colors are incredibly vibrant. Just looking at the regular old home screen on the device is a treat, but it gets even better when you play colorful games like Angry Birds or watch videos through YouTube.

Now, I’m normally the kind of person who prefers a hardware keyboard for its improved accuracy and tactile feedback, but I was able to type quite well using the on-screen QWERTY keyboard on the Captivate. This might be thanks to the slightly larger four-inch display, offering slightly better key separation both in landscape and portrait modes. There’s also Swype in there, should you feel so inclined, but I liked the QWERTY. There is some haptic feedback too (which you can turn off in the options), if that happens to be your kind of thing.

It’s Not Vanilla Android

As can be expected with all the Galaxy S devices from Samsung, the Captivate does not rock a “clean” installation of Android. Instead, it features the Samsung TouchWiz 3.0. This is quite an improvement over previous TouchWiz releases, but I wouldn’t say that it is a big selling point beyond regular old Android.

You get a total of seven home screens, each of which can be populated with your choice of shortcuts, scrollable widgets, and other personalizations. There are “live wallpapers” in there too, but you’d probably want to keep those to a minimum if you want to get better battery life out of this phone. Perhaps the biggest difference is how the apps are displayed in the main menu. Rather than having the usual vertical scrolling in Android, you get app “pages” much like the iPhone. I can’t say if this is better or worse; it’s just different.

Some pre-installed apps include the Daily Briefing (with news and weather), Feeds and Updates (for social media integration), Aldiko eBook, Layar, Samsung Apps, Social Hub, ThinkFree Office, Voice Recorder, and Write and Go. This is addition to the usual Google services like Gmail and Navigation.

Darn Those Touch-Sensitive Controls

Underneath the four-inch display are four soft keys: menu, home, back, and search. These are pretty standard fare among Android devices, but I found that the touch-sensitive nature led to some quibbles. I’d be in the middle of playing a game or surfing the web in landscape mode when I accidentally touched one of the touch-sensitive buttons, putting me somewhere I didn’t want to be.

This may have been only with the review unit I received, but I found that the phone sometimes thought I pressed the search button (which brings up the quick search box) even when my finger was nowhere near it. I understand that having a flush display and flush soft keys makes for a svelter overall appearance, but it is a source of some frustrations too.

Design and Battery Life

As can be expected with any modern smartphone rocking such a large display, battery life on the Samsung Galaxy S Captivate leaves a little something to be desired. Under moderate usage, I was barely able to get a day out of the phone. If I put on a slightly extended session of mobile gaming, this was shortened even further, linking me up with a wall outlet more often than I would have liked. This really is par for the course when it comes to phones like this, and it’s not as bad as the EVO 4G, but just be aware that you may need an extra battery or easy access to power on the go.

In terms of design, the somewhat larger bezel around the four-inch screen makes for a rather large footprint for the Captivate. It’ll still fit in most pockets, thanks largely to its slim profile, but it is a little bit on the big side. Two features that are quite positive, however, are the USB connector and the battery cover. Instead of a flimsy rubber flap, Samsung used a sliding door to protect the USB connector at the top of the phone. I like that.

Similarly, you remove the carbon fiber-look metal battery cover not by sliding it out, but by sliding the lowermost portion on the back of the phone. This gives the metal plate enough room to slide downward ever so slightly. The “click and lock” nature of that lowermost portion gives some reassurance that you won’t accidentally slide off the battery door unexpectedly.

Conclusion

Now that the Google Nexus S is available, you may have some second thoughts about picking up the marginally older Samsung Galaxy S platform. Don’t be. The Captivate is a seriously solid phone with a beautiful display, plenty of horsepower, and all the Google integration you’ve come to expect.

The build quality feels quite good, the slim profile is a plus, and the little details (like the sliding cover for the USB port) make this a great choice for Android fans. Better still, Rogers has reduced the price on this phone to $100 on contract, making it a good value to boot. Some other folks have voiced their concerns over the GPS and voice input accuracy, but I experienced none of these issues. Unequivocally, the Captivate is one of the best Android phones available through Rogers right now. That might change in the near future, as with so many other types of tech, but for now, the Captivate is a solid buy.

[Rogers, AT&T, T-Mobile, Verizon, Sprint]


Posted in: Uncategorized

10 Comments

  1. This is cool! And so interested! Are u have more posts like this? Plese tell me, thanks

  2. Andrew says:

    The captivate is a great phone but I would suggest getting a phone that comes with current firmware. If we are waiting this long for froyo, there is a good chance we will never see any update after froyo. I am a little sorry I didn’t wait for the nexus s or just get the nexus one.

  3. Lynn says:

    I have been searching the market for a new phone and just really trying to figure out what to go with. This review has really made me turn away from the i side and have more of a open mind. The screen looks awesome and I really like the size of it as the touch keypad is sometimes to close.
    Thank you for the review its really helped.

  4. @Chris: I did not use the GPS while driving, no. Personally, I rarely use my smartphone for navigation unless I’m somewhere totally unfamiliar, but I understand that other people are different. I would have followed up with a GPS driving test on the phone, but it’s already packed up to be shipped back to Samsung today.

  5. nightfly2000 says:

    there is a GPS fix out on the android market. Works excellent now.

    I can go 2 days with moderate use.(be sure to properly condition the battery and use a usb charger with 1 amp, not the .7 amp that comes with the phone… thats a bluetooth charger)… live wall papers though eat the battery.

    With a froyo custom rom, the official will be released soon, will fix the GPS. the battery life will be inptoved as well because they have changed a few co-efficients in the coore apps.

    i think the captivate is a wonderful device, just android 2.1 has not been optimized, and thats why 2.2 has been delayed for so long, as they are trying to get this right. there are rumors that gingerbread will be next instead of froyo (for the captivate), but dont expect that as gingerbread has just been released from google and has not been tweaked for the galaxy s…

  6. UPS will be delivering my Captivate tomorrow. Took advantage of the great price, and as a long-time Rogers customer, was given an incredible plan & pricing.

  7. emma says:

    ony got it tni hav an iphone way prefare this already

  8. Chris says:

    Did you actually use the GPS while driving? Many people say their GPS works fine because they think getting a lock while standing still means it works. Actually, I found that many people think this way. You went into detail about how certain features are great but you BARELY covered the hot topic for this phone…which is the GPS. Did you actually use it while driving? How accurate was it? Please go into more detail in that because everyone already knows how awesome the screen is, how light the phone is, how small it is, etc…..but the hot topics are not covered at all.

  9. M.Liza says:

    I’ve been thinking of getting a new phone but wasn’t sure where to go. This is a really good review, I love touch screens and being able to play games in my phone! now I’m seriously considering to get a Samsung Galaxy

Leave a Comment