Home » Uncategorized » Google-Justice fight looks more like trade-secret protection

Google-Justice fight looks more like trade-secret protection

The Google struggle with the U.S. Justice Department has more to do with trade secrets than with individual privacy, experts say. Despite the individual outcry that followed the Government’s announcement, legal analysts and Google executives alike see no reason for “normal” users to panic.

“This particular subpoena does not raise serious privacy issues,” said Timothy Wu, a law professor at Columbia.

The American Civil Liberties Union, always a champion of individual rights, will be supporting Google but not on privacy grounds. “We will probably not be making that argument,” ACLU lawyer Aden J. Fine said.

The ACLU itself is the source of the brouhaha, having challenged the Child Online Protection Act, a 1998 law that has yet to see the light of legal day because of injunctions. One of the main arguments made by the Government is that Internet searches will reveal offensive materials that computer-based filters will not stop. And the Government has asked the major Internet search engine companies to provide frameworks for testing that hypothesis.

Google lawyer Ashok Ramani has asserted that the company was fighting the seizure mandate more for company business reasons than for any user-friendly reasons. “Google objects,” Ramani argued, “because to comply with the request could endanger its crown-jewel trade secrets.”

Indeed, that seems more likely as the main reason for Google to resist. Yahoo, America Online, and MSN have already turned over information demanded by the U.S. Government subpoena. Representatives of all of those companies said they saw no reason not to comply because they found no privacy issues in releasing the information to the Government.

Google has yet to respond to the subpoena officially in court. That day might come soon. If current thinking is any guidebook, the Internet search giant will continue to refuse what it sees as efforts to raid its company store secrets.

About Dave White

Check Also


Try Oculus Rift And Wii To Roam Around On The Back To The Future Hoverboard

Check out how you can fly in virtual space by using an Oculus Rift and a Wii Balance Board.


Amazon Appstore for Android Holiday Deals, Including Free Apps

There are tons of deals from the Amazon Appstore that will be offered starting now and throughout the holiday shopping season. They say that they will have "hundreds of titles that are eitehr free... or available between 50-90% off" the regular price.


Black Friday: Google Play Store Apps, Games and Content on Sale All Weekend

Case in point, if you head over to the Google Play Store right now, you'll find that Google is celebrating all Cyber Weekend with discounts on all sorts of content. This includes many popular apps and games


Black Friday Deal: Samsung Galaxy Tab 3 10.1-Inch for $100 Off

Did you manage to score any epic Black Friday deals this morning? Are you still ...


Arduino Co-Creator Releases Plans for $200 DIY Mobile Phone

Mellis was one of the people who came up with the now hugely popular Arduino platform and now he has come up with plans for people to build their own cell phone for about $200 in parts.


No Discounts for Apple Black Friday, Just Free Gift Cards

If you were hoping to save yourself some cash as you brave the Black Friday shopping crowds, you'll want to go somewhere other than the official Apple Stores.